Elmlawn Cemetery / Church — Haunted Place in Tonawanda, New York

years ago, a young woman was just married to the love of her life in that church. And she was crossing the street to go in their "get away carriage”, she was run over and killed instantly by an oncoming carriage. It has been said that you can still see her cross the street after dark!

📍 Elmlawn Cemetery / Church, Tonawanda, NY · View on Google Maps ↗

Experience Tonawanda's haunted history in person

Join a guided ghost tour and visit the most chilling sites in the area.

Find Ghost Tours in Tonawanda →

More Haunted Places in Tonawanda

Elmlawn Cemetery

Tonawanda, NY

At night orbs can be seen, when driving by this cemetery. A number of unidentified lights as well…

Mighty Taco on Eggert Street

Tonawanda, NY

The cooler in the back, and surrounding areas outside the cooler by the dumpster is said to be the…

See all haunted places in Tonawanda →