Madonna Cemetery — Haunted Place in New Castle, Pennsylvania

A tombstone lies here with a picture of a man who has, one white hand and one Black Hand on it. Legend states that if you put a white sheet over the top of the headstone on All Hollow's Eve (October 30), at midnight and knock 3 times, the man will appear behind you.

📍 Madonna Cemetery, New Castle, PA · View on Google Maps ↗

Experience New Castle's haunted history in person

Join a guided ghost tour and visit the most chilling sites in the area.

Find Ghost Tours in New Castle →

More Haunted Places in New Castle

Coverts Crossing

New Castle, PA

in the early 1940's there was a girl that was on her way home from her high school prom and ended…

Harmony Short Line

New Castle, PA

On October 30th 1904 at 11:50 PM, there was a railroad conductor hit and killed while he was…

Hillsville Road

New Castle, PA

A ghost train can be seen on foggy nights off of Hillsville Road in New Castle. Also, there are…

Shenango Township

New Castle, PA

The old Whitemen Homestead is haunted by several ghost. There is a spirit of a civil soldier that…

See all haunted places in New Castle →